Otto Tomotto's Good Italian Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to Otto Tomotto's Good Italian, a charming Italian eatery nestled in the heart of Victor, NY. Known for its inviting ambiance, this restaurant is perfect for both casual family dinners and larger gatherings. The menu features generous portions of classic Italian dishes, with standout items like the crispy eggplant parmigiana and the indulgent seafood mac. Diners rave about the tomato basil clam chowder and homemade bread, served warm with soft butter—ideal for whetting your appetite.

Vegetarian options abound, ensuring that every palate is catered for. The service is consistently praised for its warmth and attentiveness, with many guests noting the presence of the beloved 'Mama' overseeing the dining experience. Whether you're seeking a leisurely lunch or a festive dinner, Otto Tomotto's combines quality food, a welcoming atmosphere, and the joy of authentic Italian cuisine.

Ottos Signature Grilled Pizza Appetizers

The Original Tomotto Pizza

Fresh tomato sauce, grilled pizza crust and smothered with asiago, mozzarella, herb seasoned ricotta, and grated romano cheeses.

$$9.95

Mushroom Two Way Pizza

The grilled crust, tomato sauce, portobello button mushrooms slowcooked in red wine with fresh garlic and herbs, sprinkle with mozzarella cheese.

$$9.95

The Clam Pie

Alfredo, bacon, peppers onions, of course, clams, mozzarella, on our signature grilled pizza crust, finished with oregano spiked bread crumbs.

$$10.95

Bruschetta

Marinated tomatoes, ricotta olive oil, on warm slices of grilled Italian bread.

$$6.99

Greens Beans

Escarole cannellini beans, garlic, chicken stock parmesan.

$$7.95

Crispy Cauliflower

Cauliflower in a tempura batter of rice flour, with banana pepper aioli fresh basil parmesan.

$$7.95

Otto Chips

House cooked potato chips, loaded with roasted peppers, scallions, alfredo sauce, bacon, olives and asiago cheese. Theyre Italian nacho.

$$9.95

Crab Cakes

3huge crab cakes pan fried served over a house made cajun slaw.

$$10.95

Calamari

Fried seasoned, served with hot banana peppers, fresh tomato sauce poppy seed dipping sauce.

$$9.95

Mozzarella Carozza

Mozzarella, layered with white bread, lightly fried in an egg batter with tomato sauce to dip.

$$8.95

Cleveland Brussels Sprouts

Fresh Brussels, deep fried with bacon in a walnut, caper vinaigrette.

$$7.95

Lasagna Dip

Classic lasagna filling, beef, cheese, sausage tomato sauce served with grilled bread.

$$8.95

Appetizers

Salads

Caesar Salad

Fresh romaine hearts mixed with asiago cheese, classic caesar dressing, croutons.

$$7.95

Tomotto Mozzarella Salad

Field greens, with fresh mozzarella and Roma, tomatoes, drizzled with balsamic vinaigrette, and fresh basil.

$$7.95

House Salad

Greens, tomatoes, olives, croutons, onions.

$$6.95

Mediterranean Salad

Artichoke, olives, tomottos, mozzarella, and Roasted Peppers, Romaine.

$$8.95

Ottos Lasagna

Hearty Italian lasagna made with ground beef, Italian sausage, gobs of ricotta cheese, layered with plenty of tomato sauce whole basil leaves, topped with melted mozzarella.

$$16.95

Shells Shells Shells Shells

Four cheese stuffed shells served with a meatball and plenty of homemade tomato sauce.

$$16.95

Cavittelli, Sausage, Peppers, Onions Mozzarella

Cavatelli with our crumbled homemade sausage, sauteed peppers onions, in our fresh tomato sauce baked with mozzarella cheese.

$$17.95

Mamas Greens Beans Gnocchi

Tender potato gnocchi, served in garlicky greens and beans sauce, topped with parmesan cheese.

$$17.95

Eggplant Pasta

Lightly fried and served over spaghettini, smothered in our fresh tomato sauce and topped with melted ricotta mozzarella cheese.

$$15.99

Chicken Pasta

Lightly fried and served over spaghettini, smothered in our fresh tomato sauce and topped with melted ricotta mozzarella cheese.

$$16.99

Veal Parmesan Pasta

Lightly fried and served over spaghettini, smothered in our fresh tomato sauce and topped with melted ricotta mozzarella cheese.

$$18.99

Tortellini Pomodoro

Cheese filled tortellini with garlic, shallots, basil fresh tomatoes in a creamy vodka sauce.

$$17.95

Penne Gorgonzola

Penne pasta tossed with artichoke hearts, sundried tomatos and mushrooms, in a gorgonzola cream sauce.

$$17.95

Pasta Puttanesca

Garlic, shallots, basil, capers, fresh tomottos, kalamata olives and a hint of spicy anchovy paste, in a roasted garlic tomato sauce, over penne.

$$17.95

Pasta Bolognese With Red Sauce

A classic meat sauce of veal, pork, and beef, slowcooked with garlic herbs, tossed with penne pasta and baked with mozzarella.

$$17.95

Pasta Bolognese With Rosa Sauce

A classic meat sauce of veal, pork, and beef, slowcooked with garlic herbs, tossed with penne pasta and baked with mozzarella.

$$18.95

Otto Tomottos Pasta Your Way

$$14.95

Otto Tomottos Risotto Your Way

$$14.95

Pasta

8 Ate 8

Eggplant Parmesan Lunch

Over spaghettini pasta.

$$8.00

Stuffed Shells Lunch

With a meatball.

$$8.00

Spaghetti With Meatballs Lunch

$$8.00

Fettuccine Alfredo With Chicken Lunch

$$8.00

Lasagna With Tomato Sauce Lunch

$$8.00

Soup Salad Combo Lunch

$$8.00

Meatball Sub Lunch

$$8.00

Greens Beans Lunch

With parmesan cheese.

$$8.00

Brushetta Haddock

Baked piece of haddock with lemon and dill, served over a bed of slow roasted veggies, and topped with our classic bruschetta mix, along with parmesan cheese curls drizzled balsamic vinegar.

$$17.95

Italian Fish Fry

Haddock breaded pan seared, roasted in the oven with roasted peppers, capers, kalamata olives artichoke hearts, finished with herb butter lemon, over a bed of spaghetti finished with romano cheese.

$$17.95

Goat Cheese Chicken Risotto

Diced grilled chicken with rosemary, cream goat cheese all cooked together with arborio rice finished with parmesan.

$$17.95

Bloody Mary Risotto

Creamy risotto with bloody mary spicy onions shrimp in a light tomato sauce topped with celery.

$$17.95

Grilled Salmon

Fresh Atlantic salmon, lightly breaded and grilled, served over your choice of roasted veggies or greens beans.

$$18.95

Mahi Mahi

Grilled mahimahi, over parmesan risotto, topped with an Italian relish.

$$18.95

Grilled Roasted

Your choice of either chicken, tuna or salmon, grilled to perfection and served with a medley of slowroasted vegetables in a kalamata olive tomato sauce.

$$18.95

Shrimp Bacon Risotto

Arborio rice, cooked with fresh herbs, shrimp, bacon, peas mushrooms, in a light garlic cream, finished with romano cheese and drizzle of white truffle.

$$18.95

Chicken Under A Brick

Parsley marinated chicken breast, grilled under a brick, to ensure tenderness, served over an Italian potato salad, served with grilled veggies drizzle of extra virgin olive oil.

$$17.95

Pork Diane

Hin slices of pork loin, over a mustard fried potato, topped with a creamy wild mushroom marsala sauce.

$$18.95

Steak Potatoes

14oz. Strip steak with Tuscan sea salt served with garlic roasted mashed potatoes.

$$19.95

Chicken French

Pan fried with an egg batter and cooked in a lemon sherry wine, butter sauce over spaghetti.

$$17.95

Chicken Cacciatore

Italian chicken nuggets, chunks of Italian sausage, peppers onions in a spicy tomato sauce tossed with penne pasta.

$$18.95

Chicken Broccoli

Seared chicken breast, sauteed with garlic, shallots and broccoli, in a light cream sauce over fettuccini, finished with parmesan cheese.

$$17.95

Seafood Mac Cheese

Crab, baby shrimp, cheesy roasted pepper alfredo, tossed with penne baked with bread crumbs.

$$18.95

Chicken Pignoli

Grilled chicken, sauteed with garlic, shallots, basil, fresh tomottos and slices of fresh mozzarella, in a white wine chicken stock reduction tossed with spaghettini toasted pine nuts.

$$17.95

Linguine With White Clam Sauce

$$17.95

Linguine With Red Clam Sauce

$$17.95

Chicken Pomadoro

Chicken, sauteed with garlic, shallots, basil fresh tomottos, in a vodka cream sauce finished with parmesan cheese served over spaghettini.

$$17.95

Seafood Mushroom

Portabella, escarole, parmesan, in a creamy pesto cream, seared day boat scallops shrimp.

$$18.95

Buffalo Chicken Pasta

Grilled chicken with garlic, shallots, basil, mushrooms, green peppers and sun dried tomottos, in a light buffalo cream sauce, tossed with penne pasta blue cheese crumbles.

$$17.95

Seafood Tomotto Fra Diavlo

Shrimp scallops, sauteed with garlic, shallots, and basil, in a spicy chunky tomato sauce over fettuccine.

$$19.95

Chicken Marsala

Rich mushroom marsala wine sauce served over penne.

$$17.95

Veal Marsala

Rich mushroom marsala wine sauce served over penne.

$$18.95

Shrimp Sausage Diablo

Shrimp sausage, garlic, shallot, basil, escarole, tomottos kalamata olives in spicy tomato sauce with penne pasta.

$$19.95

Seafood Pesto

Shrimp scallops with garlic, shallot, mushrooms, olives artichoke hearts, tossed in a pesto cream sauce over linguine.

$$19.95

Cajun Shrimp Pasta

Shrimp, garlic, shallots, basil, mushrooms, peppers sundried tomottos, creamy cajun sauce fettuccine.

$$19.95

Veggie Pasta

Zucchini, squash, red onion, eggplant other seasonal root veggies, butter, olive oil and oregano tossed with linguine pasta romano cheese.

$$17.95

C Food Medley

Shrimp, scallops, clams mussels with garlic, shallot, basil, mushrooms, olives, broccoli sundried tomottos, in white wine butter sauce linguine.

$$19.95

Entrees

Desserts

Italian Tubolare

Italian bread deep fried, tossed with cinnamon sugar, stuffed with buttercream frostings.

$$6.00

Seattles Best Coffee

$$2.49

The Classic

Vanilla buttercream, a drizzle of honey, powdered sugar.

$$6.00

The Flavored Coffee Of The Day

$$2.99

The Chocolate

Chocolate butter cream, chocolate sauce cocoa powder.

$$6.00

The Strawberry

Strawberry buttercream strawberry sauce.

$$6.00

The Pistachio

Pistachio butter cream pistachio ? cranberry biscotti crumble.

$$6.00

Tubolare Of The Day

$$9.00

Homemade Ice Cream

$$2.00

Cleveland Brussel Sprouts Lunch

Bacon, Brussels, walnut caper vinegarette.

$$7.95

Cauliflower Fritta Lunch

Rice flour tempura, banana pepper aioli, basil, parmesan.

$$7.95

Greens Beans Lunch

Escarole, beans, chicken stock, parmesan.

$$5.95

Fried Calamari Lunch

Banana peppers, lemon, poppy seed, tomato sauce.

$$8.95

Crab Cakes Lunch

Cajun slaw, remoulade.

$$8.95

Lunch Appetizers

Lunch Salads

House Salad Lunch

Greens, tomottos, olives, croutons, onion.

$$6.95

Caesar Salad Lunch

Romaine, asiago, creamy caesar, croutons.

$$7.95

Tomotto Mozzarella Salad Lunch

Greens, housemade mozzarella, roma tomatos, basil.

$$7.95

Mediterranean Salad Lunch

Artichoke, olives, tomatoes, mozzarella, Peppers, Romaine.

$$7.95

Parmesan Sangwhich Lunch

Chicken, veal or eggplant, mozzarella, tomotto sauce.

$$8.95

Chicken Parmesan Sandwich Lunch

With mozzarella, tomato sauce.

$$8.95

Veal Parmesan Sandwich Lunch

With mozzarella, tomato sauce.

$$8.95

Eggplant Parmesan Sandwich Lunch

With mozzarella, tomato sauce.

$$8.95

Chicken Parmesan Wrap Lunch

With mozzarella, tomato sauce.

$$8.95

Veal Parmesan Wrap Lunch

With mozzarella, tomato sauce.

$$8.95

Eggplant Parmesan Wrap Lunch

With mozzarella, tomato sauce.

$$8.95

Grilled Chicken Sandwich Lunch

Pesto, peppers, mozzarella, lettuce, tomotto.

$$8.95

Grilled Bread Sandwich Lunch

Pesto, peppers, mozzarella, lettuce, tomotto.

$$8.95

The OTTO Burger Lunch

Smoked bacon, garlic mayo, cheddar.

$$9.95

Triple Layer Panini Lunch

Chicken, pesto, fresh mozzarella, portabella.

$$8.95

Veggie Wrap Lunch

Roasted veggies, pesto, mozzarella, lettuce.

$$8.95

Eggplant Fresco Sandwich Lunch

Balsamic, basil, fresh mozzeralla, mesclun.

$$7.95

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich Lunch

Lettuce, tomato, blue cheese.

$$8.95

Sausage Sander Sandwich Lunch

Peppers, onions, mozzarella.

$$8.95

Mamas Chicken Wrap Lunch

Peppers, lettuce , tomotto, pesto, asiago.

$$8.95

Ceasar Wrap Lunch

Romaine, asiago, and croutons.

$$8.95

Lunch Sandwiches Wraps

Lunch Pasta

Tortellini Funghi Lunch

Mushrooms, bacon, peas, garlic cream sauce, parmesan.

$$10.95

Fra Diavolo Fettuccini Lunch

Garlic, kalamata olives, tomato sauce, chili flakes.

$$10.95

Shrimp Pasta Lunch

Capers, roasted peppers, lemon, wine, artichoke, parmesan.

$$12.95

Sausage Linguine Pesto Lunch

Pesto, housemade sausage, romano cheese.

$$11.95

Lasagna Lunch

Beef, sausage, ricotta, mozzarella.

$$12.95

Eggplant Parmesan Pasta Lunch

$$11.95

Chicken Parmesan Pasta Lunch

$$12.95

Veal Parmesan Pasta Lunch

$$13.95

Stuffed Rigatoni Lunch

Housemade sausage, rosa sauce, mozzarella.

$$12.95